The Online Magazine
of Motion Picture
and Television
Music Appreciation
Film Score Monthly Subscribe Now!
film score daily 

This News Friday 1/9/98

by Lukas Kendall

I was just at something very cool. It was the dedication for the reopening of the Newman scoring stage at 20th Century Fox, which had been closed for renovations the past few years. The new stage retains the dimensions and many materials from the original, restoring the location of the control booth and adding a state of the art board.

Among the guests were seemingly dozens of Newmans--including Randy, David and Tom--as well as John Williams, who gave the "dedication" as it were, along with Fox head of music Robert Kraft. I've interviewed Williams and heard him speak a few times, but this was the most enthused I've ever seen him--he talked about playing in the orchestra under Alfred Newman and the first time he ever set foot on the stage, as a boy in the late 1930s.

We'll have tons o' photos in an upcoming FSM.

News

Here is what people are dying to know. But, there aren't answers yet: I don't know if there will be a Vol 2 of Tomorrow Never Dies, as people have speculated and as David Arnold wants. I also haven't heard of any plans for a Vol 2 of Titanic--the current album is tearing up charts, logging in at #11 on the Billboard 2000, thanks to Ms. Dion no doubt.

And there is no one signed yet to replace Jerry Goldsmith on Lost in Space, although the most mentioned "frontrunner" (not confirmed by the studio, however) is Mark Isham. No doubt people will be shocked to hear this since he's such a not-the-obvious choice for a retro sci-fi film.

But, some definite news: there will be an expanded Close Encounters of the Third Kind CD released some time this year by Arista--a commercial release, not anything tied to the laserdisc. Complete score, produced by Shawn Murphy, like the expanded E.T. disc. Groovy.

Shirley Bassey turned 61 yesterday (1/8/97). (Thanks to Steve Head for the info.)

Looking for a cool John Williams site? Try http://www.sestran.com/~accaaa/jwsite/index.html

My Mission Statement

I got some wonderful responses to my Mission Statement from last Monday. Most were quite lengthy, and a few personal, so I won't be printing them. Most people are supportive of FSM and I thank them all for their comments. (The people who are not supportive do not bother to write me personally. Let's hear it for skewed sample sizes!)

In short, thanks, and keep reading!

Horner Corner

James Horner will be on Los Angeles PBS KCET-TV, Wednesday, January 14, 7:30PM, with an interview and footage from the dubbing of The Mask of Zorro. It will probably be rebroadcast throughout the day.

From: Jeff S McNurlin <jeffsm@earthlink.net>

    A visitor of your site was wondering about the music played as the Titanic sank. You thought it was period music but you weren't sure. Well, you're right. I don't remember the exact title, but all the music played by the musicians is based on survivors accounts. In the 1953 version of Titanic, they played the same piece (the sad one), except in the old version the passengers sang the words with it.

Was it "Slap Your Bitch Up"?

From: TERRY GOETT <"pentium@voyager.net"@voyager.net>

    I would like to say that your comments about Horner's music are certainly very biased. I tried to figure out why you and others of your type try to find problems with every one his scores. In my humble opinion I see you as being like the movie critic and becomes anal with minor details instead of viewing it as entertainment. I will agree with you however, with the comment that Titanic is definately not the greatest score ever, but when seen in the film it adds a decent amount of character to the motion picture. I would like to hear your opinions on his earlier scores: Krull, ST2, ST3, Brainstorm, Willow, Glory, Cocoon, and Land Before Time. If you do not agree that these are at least good scores than Williams's kiddie style is probably perfect for you.

I'm definitely not getting into an argument about Horner vs. Williams and who has the most "kiddie" style (although I think I am going to listen to that great kiddie score, Images). Here are my opinions on the listed Horner scores:

Krull, Star Trek 2 and 3, Brainstrorm: my favorite years of his work, I like these all a great deal. As I've listened to more music I've become familiar with the classical origins of a lot of his licks, but they are all terrific film scores, Brainstrom especially. Star Trek III is a little lazy.

Willow: I like some of it but the shakuhachi wears thin, so do the classical rip offs, and the source cue which is like early '80s Trevor Jones source music (Dark Crystal). CD seems to go on for seventeen years. I still don't know how they squeezed all 73 minutes onto the LP of it which I used to have. You know what I love? The choral phrase over the Paramount logo.

Glory: I am in the minority in that I find this cloying and hard to swallow. War is hell, dammit. By the way, that's not the Harlem Boys Choir actually on the soundtrack--they couldn't learn it in time so session singers were employed.

Cocoon: Love some of it, the Billy May swing music gets tiresome. Lift from Star Trek II too much to bear.

Land Before Time: I love the first 70 seconds, but I am not a fan of this type of animated story and the score was just too cute for me.

Well, you asked. I'm not telling people what they should like but these are my personal reactions.

From: Ccmillar <Ccmillar@aol.com>

    I always enjoy reading your material, and have been buying and/or looking at FSM for a few years now. I happen to be a composer myself, of film music and otherwise, and I'm a huge fan of James Horner.

    He is in demand because he is consistent, delivers the emotional goods, and helps makes movies a more wonderful experience. There's no denying that.

    Any good composer might repeat himself. It actually set his style. We recognize Horner because it "sounds like Horner!" All the more credit to him! He sets moods, sounds, motifs, and really composes within his framework throughout a score. There's usually always some new and interesting orchestration or two in any of his works, and it's amazing now how many other scores sound like Horner's work at this point in time. He's been as big an influence as the heavyweights who have been around a long time as well (Goldsmith, Williams, et al.)

    I have a problem with your admiration for Patrick Doyle. I find him to be the most predictable composer around. Unoriginal, is stylstically usually always wrong for a time period-type piece, unstructured, etc. Most of his stuff sounds like a kid in a new toy shop...have to use one of these, oh!oh! and three of these...oh!oh! four of these!....etc., etc. Worst of all, he only seems to go for nothing but the emotional heartstrings; not building on any motifs, etc. Maybe I'm too harsh, but I haven't seen everything he's done. I stopped my interest in him when he started singing in his own scores. Please!

Sure, let's pick on the guy with leukemia. However, speaking of that, I'm told Doyle is proceeding excellently through his chemo and his cancer is in full remission. To which we can only say, thank Crom. Rent Dead Again, that one is really cool.

Questions

From: Jeff Thomas <MaestroJW@aol.com>

    I was speculating about the new Star Wars scores for the prequels, and i wondered what you think of this. Do you think the new SW score CDs will include every bit of music like the Special Editions did, I don't think they will, but i am really hoping that they do... remember really important music for scenes like the Final Duel and when Vader cut Lukes hand off took years to be released, I don't want that to happen again with the new music, it's gonna bug me to again have unreleased Star Wars music... I have virtually every incarnation and reincarnation of SW scores that were released, i hope they don't do this again, but i have this terrible feeling that they will.

RCA Victor has had terrific success with their 2CD sets this year--the album to Star Wars went gold recently--and I think we'll see pretty complete representations of the new scores as they come out. But, 2CD sets are always harder to sell than one disc, so maybe they will stagger them. I don't know. It's still far off.

From: "Jeffry D. Heise" <jdh@socialstudies.com>

    Yes, there have been other filmmusic composers who have taken up the baton. Alfred Newman and Miklos Rosza used to conduct both the LA Philharmonic and the Hollywood Bowl Symphony orchestra from the 40's into the 60's, and there are recordings on older Capitol lps and EMI CD's of their output. Andre Previn was the principal conductor and musical director of the LA Philharmonic in the 60's and 70's. Max Steiner was the principal conductor for one of the major theaters in NYC before he came out to Hollywood in 1929. And if I'm not mistaken, wasn't Bernard Herrmann in charge of the CBS Radio Symphony orchestra in the 30's?

I forget what the question was but this is a useful answer. Thanks!

From: Warren Hsu <wvh@TSO.Cin.IX.Net>

    Hello there! I'm searching for an excellent pops orchestra CD which contains suites from the modern Disney classics (Little Mermaid, B&tB, Aladdin, Lion King, etc...).

    I am aware of the recent Cincinnati Pops Orchestra CD which contains suites from LM, B&tB, A, and LK, but it also features the Indiana Singing Hoosiers Chorus, and that pretty much ruined it for me...are there any other CDs which contain more or less just orchestral suites of the abovementioned? Maybe Boston Pops?

Hulk at loss. Readers, please help.

One More Time, the Judge Dredd/LIS Trailer Music

The music in the Lost in Space trailer is the piece Jerry Goldsmith wrote originally for the Judge Dredd trailer--another film he was at one time going to score. There is an orchestral recording of the piece on the Varese Sarabande compilation Hollywood '95. I don't know of any further plans to release it.

A Good Joke

From: Jeffswim <Jeffswim@aol.com>

    It seems in your 1997 film score wrapup you neglected to mention what I believe to be the best score of 1997: Rosewood (John Williams). I noticed you were looking at only films released after Memorial Day, so maybe you were only focusing om those. Anyway, a lot of people have forgotten about this score, and the entire film for that matter. I thought it was riveting, and the score complemented every scene. Unlike many scores Mr. Foster has heard, this one did not grow on me...it had me from the start. Hopefully the Academy will remember it on Feb. 10.

Want a good joke? What do Lukas Kendall and John Williams (and probably JeffSwim) have in common? We are the only white people who saw Rosewood. I was going to tell this joke to John Williams tonight but forgot. However, Randy Newman thought it was funny. I liked the Rosewood score a lot, but I doubt it will be nominated since the movie was so dismissed.

Film Music on TV this Weekend

Don't forget to check this site for cool scores to this weekend's movies-on-TV fare: http://columbia.digiweb.com/~ellenbe/fmtvindex.html

Something Else That's Funny

Fans get so riled up about their favorite composers and scores. I should know, I've made my career, such as it has begun to be, by stirring people up. But at this event tonight, the dedication of the Newman Stage, I ran into so many people who I know for a fact either cannot stand me or cannot stand each other. I mean, rival agents, or composers, or competing studio personnel. But you know what? Nobody really cares. It's like here, have a cocktail. I ran into John Frizzell whom I was led to believe was out for my head because we gave Alien 4 a bad review, and he's like, hey, how's it going?

It's like, who gives a shit? I'll bet John Williams sure doesn't. It was cool to hear him talk about Alfred Newman since he seemed so genuinely interested. Here's a guy who is either unable or unwilling to remember any details of some of the most famous movies of all time which he scored, and he remembers everything about a recording session from 1955 and how Alfred Newman came over to talk to him one day and how nervous he was.

I wonder if we put arguing people from rec.music.movies in a room together if they'd be fighting or if they'd be having a drink. I read an article about social norms on the plane recently, about how law doesn't really govern people as much as our own self-adherence to social norms out of fear of being ostracized. One of those social norms is that you never want to be the person in a room making an ass out of himself. It's just funny, how in real life how mellow people can be, when if you read it on the Internet, you would think composer X would be in a duel to the death with composer Y if given the chance. In actuality it's like in the Godfather: "It's just business," without the killing. The fact is, deep down it's easier to be nice to people. Except maybe for Sam Schwartz.

I've been around fans when meeting a composer--generally an awkward experience--and I just wish all of you guys could do it more often, or at all, because after a while you mellow out and can actually have a conversation without being self-conscious and geeky. (Another reason to do the next best thing and buy our Basil Poledouris documentary!) I've maintained all along that what I would really like to see is honest discussion and evaluation of film scoring as an art form and also as an aspect of an enormous industry. It's a really cool cultural as well as artistic thing. (I think it's the smidgen of honesty that FSM has, in addition to the craziness, that sets us apart from other zines.) I think if every geeky fan spent a day or, for it really to work, a week with a well known composer (or any celebrity), we'd all have much smarter discussions. All the tension and defensiveness would disappear and we'd realize that composers are people who work for a living like everybody else and who are aware of the merits and demerits in most things they do.

Have a nice day.

Mr. Namedropping soundtrack nerd from an island back east: Lukas@filmscoremonthly.com


Past Film Score Daily Articles

Film Score Monthly Home Page
© 1997-2012 Lukas Kendall. All rights reserved.