The Online Magazine
of Motion Picture
and Television
Music Appreciation
Film Score Monthly Subscribe Now!
film score daily 

CD Reviews: Max Steiner RKO Years and The Thin Blue Line




Max Steiner: The RKO Years, 1929-1936 ****

MAX STEINER

FMA-MS110

Disc One: 26 tracks -77:22    Disc Two: 23 tracks - 63:06    Disc Three: 23 tracks - 73:09

Film music owes Max Steiner an enormous debt of gratitude. Steiner began his pioneering work at RKO with the advent of sound pictures mostly as a conductor of musicals, which were so much in vogue at the time. The Best Picture winning western Cimarron (1931) boasted the first original film score for a "talkie," consisting only of music for the opening and closing credits. It was initially felt that music would not only interfere with the sound in non-musical "talkies," but would also confuse audiences ("Hey, where's that music coming from?"). Producer David O. Selznick (then at RKO) requested a significant amount of dramatic underscoring for Symphony of Six Million, another first for Steiner. Audiences and critics were not confused, and instead felt the music enhanced the drama -- and the rest is history.

During his tenure at RKO, Steiner would sometimes score more than a dozen pictures a year, including the ground-breaking King Kong, not included in this collection. (Check out the Stromberg/Morgan re-recording of Kong for the best CD presentation of Steiner's complete masterpiece.) Instead this new set contains all of the surviving tracks from the aforementioned Cimarron and Symphony, as well as nine other features. The music is culled primarily from acetate reference discs saved by Steiner and others, which are now a part of the Steiner collection at Brigham Young. While these are not the optimum storage method, the scores in question mostly predate the use of magnetic film storage. Plus, they were never intended to be heard outside of the films anyway, so it's a miracle we have what we do.

This collection contains a handful of little known gems from the Steiner canon, including Symphony, Bird of Paradise and Sweepings. Disc two includes lengthy suites from the classics Little Women and The Little Minister, two early Katherine Hepburn films. The best is saved for last, with disc three containing long suites from The Lost Patrol and the Oscar-winning The Informer. The Lost Patrol is a great early adventure score, and Steiner's music evokes both the plight of the soldiers and the Middle Eastern locale. The Informer features a jaunty main theme that often turns dark and moody in this Irish Judas tale. The Informer easily stands beside Steiner's later noir work at Warner Bros.

Steiner would eventually leave RKO for Warner Bros., where he spent the majority of the remainder of his years (occasionally being loaned out for little projects like Gone With the Wind). And while this later work, such as his many scores for the films of Bette Davis, are more famous, it was at RKO where Steiner developed most of the techniques which continue to be a mainstay of film scoring today. And remember, all of the proceeds from these BYU releases go to the acquisition and preservation of film music elements, so continued support for this series may just lead to your own favorite score getting to see the light of day.     -- Darren MacDonald







Music From The Thin Blue Line (1988/2003) *** 1/2

PHILIP GLASS

Orange Mountain Music OMM0007

19 tracks - 55:41

Errol Morris' avant-garde documentary The Thin Blue Line focuses on the sad fate of Randall Adams, a prisoner in the Texas penitentiary system, wrongfully accused of murder. Making use of jailhouse interviews, symbolic imagery and expressive cutting, the film actively challenges the inmate's conviction, discrediting the state's evidence as well as identifying the real killer. As a matter of fact, the filmmaker's case proved to be so convincing, Adams regained his freedom shortly after the picture's 1988 release.
For the score, Morris hired Philip Glass, the well known minimalist from Baltimore. As bleak as a visit to death row, this newly reissued opus demonstrates that reductive, postmodern works can arouse and augment emotions and ideas just as well as other forms.

Opening with "Adams' Theme," for instance, the album establishes a melancholy mood quickly as waves of lower-register notes roll back and forth relentlessly; and though a trumpet materializes, introducing a bright, contrasting melody, it eventually dissolves, overwhelmed by the ominous rush of strings and horns. A similar gloom permeates "Looking," an elegy for strings, in which a double bass, a viola and a pair of violins ascend and descend over and over, mimicking human moans and sighs.

Now and then, though, Glass shies away from strings, if not despair, and draws heavily upon the keyboard, as he does on tracks like "Boston Blackie" and "Harris' Story." And in a piece like "Adams' Nightmare," he juxtaposes metallic drums and synthesizers to generate an outer-spacey noise that betrays the influence of Glass' occasional collaborator, Brian Eno. "Miller's Theme," in contrast, borrows heavily from the rhythms and sounds of Texas Swing, electronically simulating the harmonica, the maracas and the mariachi trumpet as a steel guitar slides along like a snake.

Remixed from the original masters and freed for the first time from voice-overs and dialogue, Glass' score now displays the same sort of yearning sadness that characterizes quieter pieces by Chopin, Prokofiev -- even Leonard Cohen. And while too much of this sort of music might trigger a depressive attack, small doses of it -- of the blues, that is -- probably never killed anyone.     -- Stephen Armstrong

MailBag@filmscoremonthly.com


Past Film Score Daily Articles

Film Score Monthly Home Page
© 1997-2009 Lukas Kendall. All rights reserved.