Film Score Monthly
FSM HOME MESSAGE BOARD FSM CDs FSM ONLINE RESOURCES FUN STUFF ABOUT US  SEARCH FSM   
Search Terms: 
Search Within:   search tips 
You must log in or register to post.
  Go to page:    
 Posted:   Jan 6, 2015 - 7:01 PM   
 By:   Grecchus   (Member)

Don’t TODD-AO movies have this same curvature at the sides problem, when shown on TV?

In their original theatrical presentations, didn’t the tilt and curvature of the screen iron out these optical effects ?


I was thinking of mentioning this latter point myself, but the problem of working through it as a thought experiment was too complicated to mentally resolve without any kind of empirical evidence to back it up. It could be that in a theatre environment the leftmost and rightmost parts of the image end up falling on the black, non-reflective over-projection areas and are seldom visible. The truth is, those extreme parts of the image do not cover much surface area anyway. They only really get noticed because the brain tends to see the screen as a single window when those panning shots send everything into motion so that all the objects on the screen are moving linearly in the same direction relative to one another while the unmoving theatre environment itself will enhance the fixed edges of the screen. Ultimately, whether the curvature of the screen unbends the optical effects is hard to figure. There are other distortions that take place within a cinema. For instance, I always prefer to sit somewhere in the central zone to ensure even proportions of the screen are visible to my unaided eye, assuming I will spend just as much time looking to my left or my right. If I am ever forced to sit away from the centre of projection and off to one side, the screen will end up looking bigger on my side due to normal diminishing perspective. God only knows how the brain plays the game of compensating for the overall screen image in such a case. I do find it mildly annoying if I ever get stuck in such a situation.

 
 
 Posted:   Mar 14, 2017 - 12:54 AM   
 By:   Bob DiMucci   (Member)

I've gone through the last three years or so of releases from the Fox Cinema Archives and added to the listing in the first post those releases that should be in widescreen --- and noted how they were actually released (where known). As you might expect, the majority of them come up short in the proper transfer department. Here are the added films:

CinemaScope / Panavision (usually 2.35:1)

Air Patrol (1962) - Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Talk review]
Bachelor Flat (1962) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [DVD Talk review]
Bandolero! (1968) - ?? [An anamorphic widescreen pressed DVD was issued in 2004]
The Big Gamble (1961) – Pan-and-scan [John M. Story review on Amazon.com]
Blood and Steel (1959) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [DVD Talk review]
Blue Denim (1959) – Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Savant review]
The Bottom of the Bottle (1958) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [Home Theater Forum review]
The Day Mars Invaded Earth (1962) - Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Savant review]
Dear Brigitte (1965) – Anamorphic widescreen [Home Theater Forum review]
The Duchess and the Dirtwater Fox (1977) - ?? [An anamorphic widescreen pressed DVD was issued earlier]
Esther and The King (1960) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [Home Theater Forum review]
Five Gates To Hell (1959) - ??
A Flea In Her Ear (1968) - Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk Review]
Gang War (1958) – Pan-and-scan [randomtime review on Amazon.com]
The Gift of Love (1958) – Pan-and-scan [Abner Sam review on Amazon.com]
Good Morning, Miss Dove (1955) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [DVD Talk review]
Hand of Death (1962) – Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Talk review]
Joanna (1968) - Pan-and-scan [Home Theater Forum review]
Justine (1969) – Pan-and-scan [Rider-on-the-rain review on Amazon.com]
Kid Blue (1973) - Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk Review]
The Lieutenant Wore Skirts (1955) – Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Talk review]
Move (1970) - Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk Review]
Murder, Inc. (1960) - ?? [An anamorphic widescreen pressed DVD was issued earlier]
On The Threshold of Space (1956) – Pan-and-scan [Home Theater Forum review]
The Pleasure Seekers (1964) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [DVD Talk review]
The Purple Hills (1961) - Pan-and-scan [Home Theater Forum review]
Rx Murder (1958) - Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Talk review]
The Sad Horse (1959) - Pan-and-scan [Home Theater Forum review]
Sea Wife (1957) - ?? [Anamorphic widescreen pressed DVD issued in 2007]
Sierra Baron (1958) – Pan-and-scan [Home Theater Forum review]
The Silent Call (1961) – Widescreen (unknown if it is anamorphic) [Hose Knows review on Amazon.com]
Smiley (1956) – Pan-and-scan [DVD talk review]
Smiley Gets a Gun (1958) - Pan-and-scan [DVD talk review]
Sniper's Ridge (1961) - ??
Staircase (1969) - Non-anamorphic letterbox [Home Theater Forum review]
The Son of Robin Hood (1958) – Pan-and-scan [Noel Bjorndahl review on Amazon.com]
These Thousand Hills (1958) - Anamorphic widescreen [Home Theater Forum review]
Walk Tall (1960) – Anamorphic widescreen [Home Theater Forum review]
Woman’s World (1954) – Non-anamorphic letterboxed [DVD Talk review] [Widescreen Blu-ray issued in 2016]
Young Guns of Texas (1962) – Pan-and-scan [Amazon.com listing]


Matted Widescreen (usually 1.85:1)

Alex and the Gypsy (1976) – Full Frame [Home Theater Forum review]
Bad Medicine (1985) - Anamorphic widescreen [DVD Talk review]
The Culpepper Cattle Co. (1972) - Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [Home Theater Forum review]
Decline And Fall Of A Bird Watcher (1968) - ??
Fire Sale (1977) - Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [DVD Talk review]
The Gambler From Natchez (1954) - Full Frame [Home Theater Forum review]
I Ought To Be In Pictures (1982) – Widescreen (not clear if anamorphic) [JBinDC review on Amazon.com]
I, the Jury (1982) - Widescreen (not clear if anamorphic) [DVD Talk review] [Released on Blu-ray in 2016]
Joshua Then And Now (1985) – Full Frame [DVD Talk review]
Key Exchange (1985) - Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [DVD Talk review]
Kidco (1984) – Widescreen (1.85) (not clear if anamorphic) [DVD Talk review]
Made For Each Other (1971) – Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [Home Theater Forum review]
Mr. Billion (1977) – Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [DVD Talk Review]
The Raid (1954) – Full Frame [Morris G. Vescovi review on Amazon.com]
Sixth and Main (1977) - ??
Sodom And Gomorrah (1962) - Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk review]
Squad Car (1960) – Full Frame [DVD Talk review]
This Is My Life (1992) – Widescreen (1.77:1) [Amazon.com listing]
Together Brothers (1974) – Anamorphic widescreen (1.85:1) [ DVD Talk review]
When The Legends Die (1972) – Full Frame [DVD Talk review]
Wild On The Beach (1965) – Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk review]

 
 
 Posted:   Jul 26, 2017 - 11:10 AM   
 By:   Bob DiMucci   (Member)

The following films have been added to the list:

Games, The (1970) – Pan-and-scan [DVD Talk review]
Move Over, Darling (1963) - Anamorphic widescreen [SAE listing]

Back Door To Hell (1964) - Anamorphic widescreen [SAE listing]
Convict Stage (1965) - Anamorphic widescreen [SAE listing]

 
You must log in or register to post.
  Go to page:    
© 2024 Film Score Monthly. All Rights Reserved.
Website maintained and powered by Veraprise and Matrimont.