Film Score Monthly
Screen Archives Entertainment 208 Golden and Silver Age Classics on CD since 1996... and counting! Exclusive distribution by SCREEN ARCHIVES ENTERTAINMENT.
WHITE DOG THE CINCINNATI KID: LALO SCHIFRIN SCORES VOL. 1 (1964-1968) PROPHECY ISLANDS IN THE STREAM BLACK SUNDAY NORTHWEST PASSAGE: CLASSIC WESTERN SCORES FROM MGM VOL. 2 BULLITT MIKLOS ROZSA TREASURY (2000 EDITION) THE FIVE MAN ARMY (THE 5 MAN ARMY)
FSM HOME MESSAGE BOARD FSM CDs FSM ONLINE RESOURCES FUN STUFF ABOUT US  SEARCH FSM   
LOG IN
Forgot Login?
Register
Search Archive
Film Score Friday
Latest Edition
Previous Edition
Archive Edition
The Aisle Seat
Latest Edition
Previous Edition
Archive Edition
View Mode
Regular | Headlines
All times are PT (Pacific Time), U.S.A.
Site Map
Visits since
February 5, 2001:
13602357
© 2010 Film Score Monthly.
All Rights Reserved.
Return to Articles

Volume 1, Number 34
 
“Like the sound of fingernails on a blackboard”, “sounds like a cow with its hoof stuck in the mud”, “makes my ears bleed”, these are just some of the things said about certain musical instruments that have sound qualities that many think, shall we say, are less than ideal. Now any instrument can sound pretty horrible depending on how it’s played, but some instruments are derided for their inherent sound and no playing skills, no matter how highly developed, seem to make a difference. I’ve chosen to look at a few that can be considered dangerous weapons as much as musical instruments.
 
Bagpipe
 
Possibly the number one threat on most people’s list of deadly acoustic delivery systems is the long suffering bagpipe. There are many types of bagpipes from the highland variety of Scotland to uilleann pipes of Ireland and many more from across the world, but regardless of origin, this airbag of death and destruction threatens many the world over.
 
The main focus of fear in the bagpipe world is the highland bagpipe. Designed to accompany battles on the open grassy hills and moors of Scotland, this instrument was meant for outdoor usage only. There is no volume control and the squally out of tune notes of the chanter abetted by the never ending sound of the drones may work fine in the heat of battle, however taking them indoors is tantamount to bringing in an automatic rifle with a faulty safety and a hair trigger, it’s a risk best not taken. All buildings with warning signs at the entrances should add the highland bagpipe to the list of items strictly prohibited along with firearms, knives and explosives.
 
Accordion
 
“Lady of Spain”: Does this phrase send chills down your spine? If so you may be suffering from bellowsaphobia which is an unnatural fear of the accordion. It’s probably one of  the least loved of all instruments these days. How it got that reputation I don’t really know as the sound is not offensive, but I suspect Lawrence Welk may have had something to do with it.
 
The accordion is the Rodney Dangerfield of musical instruments getting no respect and has become more of a punch line for jokes and a cliché of musical banality than a musical instrument. The depth to which the dignity of this instrument has fallen can be summed up by the following joke: Q. What’s the definition of optimism? A. An accordion player with a business card (or alternatively, a pager).
 
Didgeridoo
 
This aboriginal Australian instrument, while not having a piercing, in your face sound, is an instrument that is perhaps just too odd for most to embrace. Although it may sound at times like a pig grunting through a cardboard tube left over from holiday gift wrapping paper affixed to its snout, the danger does not really lie in the sound itself. Rather the danger may come from a player taking offense if he sees you put your hands over your ears while he is playing. He may then feel inclined to take this mighty stick of an instrument and wielding it like a sword, smack you right up the side of your critical little head. So beware.
 
 
Steel Guitar
 
First off, I have to say I don’t like country music at all. When I hear it I swear my I.Q. lowers immediately and I feel the compulsion to buy a beer to cry into, but hey that’s just me. For that reason I have chosen the steel guitar as my own personal instrumental purveyor of pain. With its six strings (sometimes 8 or more) akin to the bullets in a standard hand gun and the slide the trigger, this weapon can assault me like no other. From the moment I’m threatened with its excruciatingly painful sliding sound, I head for cover, eventually running out of the room in a total panic.
 
There is one good thing about the steel guitar, and that is it’s electric. So if I ever find myself backed into the corner of a dark alley, trapped by a steel guitar toting madman, I can always leap forward and disarm him by unplugging its extension cord from the outlet that has so mercilessly given it the power to cause me undue harm. At that point I can bolt from the alley unscathed into the glorious golden light of day.
 
Closing Comments
 
OK, there are many instruments that people don’t like the sound of and it really comes down to personal taste. Add to that the fact that many ethnic instruments may not be accessible to people not familiar with them or the culture they come from making them just too strange sounding to their ears. I just picked a few of the more obviously fun instruments to mess with and ran with it. No malice was intended to any players or lovers of these instruments!
 
I actually don’t have any real problems with the instruments I riffed on, well except the steel guitar, that one affects me as written. In fact I like the highland bagpipes, love the uilleann pipes and have a number of Celtic music recordings containing some fantastic playing by some very skilled pipers. I owned a set of uilleann pipes myself at one time and quickly gave them up when I found out how hard it was going to be to learn to play this difficult instrument (and make the reeds), let alone master it. My hats off to those who can play it well!
 
Also, although not exactly a favorite of mine, the accordion also boasts some fine players, two that readily come to mind. One is our film score world’s own Dominic Frontiere who is also a jazz accordion legend. Second is Dick “Daddy-O” Contino, an accordion virtuoso who is still playing publicly to this day.

So as Sergeant Esterhaus from Hill Street Blues might say, “Be careful out there, there might be some dangerous instruments waiting to cause you harm at a moments notice.”


                                                Epilogue

                   The place for quotes, trivia, links, etc. 

Video of the week:   Dick Contino playing Duke Ellington's "Caravan"

  

 Be seeing you...

 

 

Return to Articles Author Profile
Comments (7):Log in or register to post your own comments
The digereedoo I can take or leave- at least the tone is not as grating as double-reeds can be.

But the simple fact is that you cannot dance a tango without a Bandoneon (cousin to the accordion), don;t let anyone tell you that the accprdion isn't hot!

Didgeridoo is a gorgeous instrument - the problem is 99% of the players are terrible because nobody knows what it can sound like, so there's no standards. People think nothing of learning to play it for a few months or a year, then performing and recording with it, promoting themselves as experts. So next time you hear a didgeridoo and think it sounds terrible, forgive the instrument and ask yourself if you'd want to spend your time listening to a beginner violinist or trumpeter play their basic exercises.

I would however nominate the shenai for this list. ;-)

well, my vote has always been for the most unpleasant, deadliest sounds-
you can't beat electric guitars/drums and the voices of pop and rock singers
loud obnoxious aggressive abrasive
give me an accordian any day
but hit the mute on heavy metal noise, rod stewart, madonna, cyndi lauper, elton john, rufus wainwright (ohmigodsomeonestophim) the list goes on
oh, and opera singers
God bless strings

well, my vote has always been for the most unpleasant, deadliest sounds-
you can't beat electric guitars/drums and the voices of pop and rock singers
loud obnoxious aggressive abrasive
give me an accordian any day
but hit the mute on heavy metal noise, rod stewart, madonna, cyndi lauper, elton john, rufus wainwright (ohmigodsomeonestophim) the list goes on
oh, and opera singers
God bless strings


Quite limited musical taste you've got there, paul. You seem to dimiss ALL of rock and pop...AND opera since the age of dawn. But hey, whatever gets your mojo workin'.

I really don't think there's any such thing as an "instrument of mass destruction" myself. It's just an instrument. It depends entirely on HOW and TO WHAT EXTENT it is used; that it is being used on its own terms etc. All of the instruments listed in Mark's article have been put to good use.

However, I agree that there's an element of association. For example, I have rather painful memories of the recorder, as everyone in primary school HAD TO play the recorder in music classes. They wailed out sour harmonies and faulty notes every week, much to my own pain (I never played, but had to endure it). But then I listened to Williams' JANE EYRE, which uses the recorder brilliantly and hauntingly. So again, it comes back to my point of using and listening to the instrument on its own terms, in tasteful settings.

Indeed. I used to be that way with the soprano saxophone, only having mostly heard it in crappy R&B. But played well it can be a pretty nice sounding instrument.

Indeed. I used to be that way with the soprano saxophone, only having mostly heard it in crappy R&B. But played well it can be a pretty nice sounding instrument.

Players such as Branford Marsalis get a great soprano tone, miles away from what Joe Public may have heard from Kenny G(orelick) and the like and it is often said in musical circles that soprano is hard to play in tune - I disagree.

The acoustic guitar as used by teeny and twenty something girls pretending to be real artists and in that extremely pretentious "unplugged" rubbish.
Electric guitars in general.
The ethnic sound. Like Vivaldi they have been used too often to not have the experience seriously obstructed by the utter kitsch it has become associated with regardless whether it's against its will.

FSMO Featured Video
Today in Film Score History:
March 18
John Kander born (1927)
William Lava born (1911)
Film Score Monthly Online
Michael, Meet Oscar
Freaks and Greeks
A Return to the Themes of Oz
Score Restore: The Goonies
Score Restore Bonus: The Hills Have Thighs
Ear of the Month Contest
Gold Rush: 1934: The Year Oscar Scored
Soundtrack Obscurities 20: A 2010 Grab Bag
© 2010 Film Score Monthly. All Rights Reserved.