Sorry, but Broxton's site just isn't for me. I like the personality Southall puts into his, the unrelenting way he'll efficiently and nicely rip a terrible score apart while having a sense of humor about it, and that he gives the scores star-based reviews. I have zero interest in wasting my time reading a two-star score review that goes on at length, only to find that out after reading the review, like at Broxton's site.
I for one hope somebody takes the initiative to archive the whole site at one of the archive websites like Archive.org/web and Exa Lead (http://www.exalead.com/search/web/submit/).