Film Score Monthly
Forgot Login?
Volume 19, No. 2
February 2014
Record Round-Up
Cover Story
Site Map
© 2021 FSM Online.
All Rights Reserved.
FSM Online

At the end of the film, Death describes Liesel’s life, and how she lived until she was 90 years old. At this time Williams provides a gorgeous transformation of Death’s theme; the melody is almost unchanged from its minor-mode origin, but now begins on a different scale degree and is set in major, altered to produce a warm (if bittersweet) feeling. Instead of sounding cold and stubborn, the theme is now affectionate and friendly, representing the sense of serene acceptance that Liesel has over her passing; the contrast between this and “Rudy Is Taken” is extreme. While perhaps slightly derivative of the piano line in the second movement of Dimitri Shostakovich’s second piano concerto, the “Finale” is a beautiful way to end the film.

Liesel herself also receives a theme, which bears some superficial resemblance to one from Williams’ Angela’s Ashes. First receiving a grandiose statement in the opening track, which serves as a sort of mini-overture for the film, the idea is then scaled back and given space to develop with Liesel. Williams chooses to use the theme mostly when she experiences events that impact her life significantly; for instance, it is hinted at on the French horn as she travels to her new home. As she walks to the house of the Nazi Burgermeister, whose wife will grant her access to a large library, we hear her theme again, indicating that reading will become a significant part of her identity; when Max gives her a painted-over copy of Mein Kampf that says “write” in Hebrew, her theme sounds once more, only this time with several new phrases added on, indicating how writing furthers her development.

The construction of this theme is noteworthy: The first five notes ascend to a wistful, yearning long-note, indicating a sense of cautious hope. However, this is short-lived, as the line soon descends down the first four notes of a minor scale; death has played an important role in shaping Liesel. These four descending notes show up in other points of the score: They are featured extensively when Hans leaves, having been drafted to fight with the Nazis. They also appear when the Burgermeister catches his wife allowing Liesel to read in their library and bans her from doing so, once again associating death with the suppression of literature.

The theme for Max, which recalls a melody from Williams’ Stepmom, is probably the most accessible in the score, although it receives very little screen time in the film. By starting with a repeated note that contrasts with the descending harmony (a harmony that, for the first four chords descends down the minor scale, starting at the tonic), Williams hints at both Max’s persistence to survive the array of obstacles in his path (the steady note) and his proximity to death (the descending harmony). This fear of Max’s untimely death is also more directly indicated; the untimely death motif is directly woven into the melody. Max’s theme does not receive much variation throughout the score, but its simple beauty provides a ray of light in a dark story.

To represent Liesel and Max’s budding relationship—and the literary fruits it brings the former—Williams writes a motif that again brings to mind one from Angela’s Ashes, to the point that it’s likely that “Plenty of Fish and Chips in Heaven” was used in the temp track at some point. In any case, the adapted version in The Book Thief is also derived from Max’s theme; the fifth, sixth, seventh and eight notes of the latter follow the same intervallic patterns as the third, fourth and fifth notes of the former. The relationship motif shows up in key moments involving their bond, including when Liesel reads H.G. Wells’ Invisible Man to Max as he attempts to recover (readings that he later says “kept me alive”), and when Liesel admits to Rudy that she is illegally hiding a Jew.

The motif is briefly referenced in the cue “The Visitor at Himmel Street.” Readers who have not yet seen the film might be surprised to learn that this serene piece accompanies a scene where a bomb lands on Himmel Street, killing almost everybody that Liesel knows. The juxtaposition between the music and the visuals—not to mention the contrast in mood between “The Visitor at Himmel Street” and the following cue, “Rudy Is Taken”—suggests that the most tragic and difficult part of death is the effect it has on the living. The Max/Liesel relationship motif represents how their relationship and Liesel’s interest in literature literally saves her life; the only reason she is not killed in the blast is because she falls asleep in the basement while writing her story in the whited-out copy of Mein Kamp that Max gave her.

So why did John Williams, who has recently chosen more projects based on the people involved (for instance, we can look to his continued collaborations with Steven Spielberg, Gloria Cheng and “The President’s Own” United States Marine Band as proof of this), decide to lend his voice to this story, of all the available options? I believe the answer lies in the attraction the 82-year old composer felt towards the thematic statements the film makes. Williams is a composer whose artistic output has impacted our society in a very profound way. Whether one credits him for sparking the Symphonic Renaissance of the ’70s and ’80s, getting people interested in all kinds of orchestral music in an era when such interest was desperately needed, or adding his own original voice to the worlds of music and of film, it is clear that his artistic decisions will continue to be felt for generations to come. Perhaps with The Book Thief Williams meant to deliver one small fact: that no matter what happens to him, he will be around for a long, long time.



FSMO on Facebook and Twitter
Search FSM Online
search tips
Print Archive
Most Popular Articles
Turning Blue: The James Horner Interview! (v14 n12)
We Have All the Time in the World: A Tribute to John Barry (v16 n2)
Inside FSM: Our Gang (v14 n12)
A Silvestri Lining, Part 1 (v15 n8)
Back to the Desert With Maurice (v15 n9)
A Special Announcement (v15 n4)
Freaks and Greeks (v15 n3)
Ho Ho Hell! (v14 n12)
Film Music News (v14 n12)
Best of 2009: Jon and Al Make a Recording (v15 n1)
More Articles
© 2021 Film Score Monthly. All Rights Reserved...